Worth booking if this price tier and vibe match your trip — only if you aren't chasing a boutique experience elsewhere.
← Back to Where to stayBoutique hotel · Shelter Island · $$$$
Sunset Beach
CoupleFirst dateIn-lawsRomanticGroupSolo
Andre Balazs's bayfront hotel and beach bar at 35 Shore Road on Crescent Beach. St. Tropez on Shelter Island. Restaurant open every day but Tuesdays for lunch and dinner.
Buzzy / sceneBeachfrontDesign-forward
Book it
- Address:
- 35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, USA
- Phone:
- (631) 749-2001
- On site:
- Beach access · Restaurant on site · Bar on site
- Open:
- Summer-only
- Good for:
- Couple · Group of friends
More places to stay near Shelter Island
- Historic waterfront hotel + cottages · Shelter IslandThe Pridwin Hotel & Cottages
- Historic inn · Shelter IslandThe Chequit
- Historic inn · Shelter IslandThe Ram's Head Inn
- Inn / hotel · Shelter IslandHouse On Chase Creek
- Inn / hotel · Shelter IslandShelter Island House
- Inn / hotel · Shelter IslandSeven on Shelter Island
Source: Hotel/operator official sites