Yes for a Sag Harbor morning stop if the specialty matches — if you want a sit-down brunch, skip it and find a diner.

Diner · Sag Harbor · $

John Papas Café

Locals' diner on Division Street, Sag Harbor. Eggs, pancakes, coffee, the village rhythm.

Specialty

Diner-style breakfast, year-round

Hours

Daily 6am-3pm

Address

112 Division St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Phone

+1-631-725-1314

Year-round

Yes

Opens

Before 7:00 AM

Outdoor seating

Source: Google Maps business listing. Last verified 2026-04-10.

Browse every spot on Coffee & Breakfast.