King Andrew Cheese

Shelter Island's cheesemonger, and it is a wagon: an 18th-century covered wagon fitted with an old Berkel slicer and real refrigeration, run by Reeve Andrew and Jessie King. A tight, curated cheese list, cured meats, condiments and bread, plus boards and catering for the house you rented. There is no storefront, so find out where the wagon is parked before you go.

@kingandrewcheese

⭐ Is it worth it? Buy a board and a loaf and eat it looking at the water. Just confirm where the wagon is standing that day.

Where: 59 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Hours: No fixed schedule published — the operator posts current hours on Instagram
Website: kingandrewcheese.com

A cheese-and-charcuterie wagon, not a shop with a door. The operator's own site gives 59 North Ferry Road; Northforker (September 2024) documents the wagon parking in two places on the island — beside Kilb's Farm Stand on Route 114, and the lot by White Oak Wine Garden kitty-corner from the IGA. Check the Instagram before you drive to one.

🧺 Also sells

🧀 Cheese
Charcuterie
🥩 Cured meats
🍞 Bread
Condiments

📍 Also in Shelter Island

Havens Farmers' Market · Farmers market
The Farmstand at Sylvester Manor · Farm stand

Source: King Andrew Cheese official website, About page — address 59 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island NY; online store and catering; hours directed to the operator's Instagram. Northforker, "Curd Appeal: King Andrew Cheese makes your dairy dreams come true on Shelter Island" (September 2024) for the operators (Reeve Andrew and Jessie King), the 18th-century covered wagon with its Berkel slicer, and the two spots it parks in — "cozied up next to Kilb's Farm Stand on the corner of Route 114 and Congdon Road" and "the lot by White Oak Wine Garden, kitty-corner from the IGA supermarket". Google Places lists King Andrew Cheese as OPERATIONAL (fetched 2026-08-15) but at 2 N Ferry Rd, which is the second of those two spots — a kilometre from the address the operator publishes. No placeId is stored on this record for that reason: the pin follows the operator's own address, and attaching a join key that resolves a kilometre away would plant a wrong pin in every audit that reads it.