🥕 Farm stand · Shelter Island · Shelter Island — ferry only

The Farmstand at Sylvester Manor

The only farm stand on Shelter Island, and it is a good one. Manor-grown produce, eggs, pork and bouquets sit alongside Balsam Farms, Catapano Dairy, Milk Pail and Wickham's — four operators this guide already lists, ferried over from the forks. Chef Susan Strauss turns the surplus into galettes, quiches and lasagna under the Manor Made label.

@sylvestermanorshelterisland4,272

Where: 21 Manwaring Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
Hours: Open 7 days a week, 9am–5pm (seasonal)
Phone: 631-749-0626
Website: sylvestermanor.org/our-farmstand

At Windmill Field, just east of the main entrance. The 236-acre Manor has farmed 60 of those acres since 2008; trails and grounds are open March–October, sunrise to sunset.