Photo coming soon — the place itself is very real.

Worth it if you're staying on Shelter Island and don't want the ferry just to reach a rental dock - genuinely the only entry on this page that puts a boat on the island itself. Call ahead; there is no staff on site to ask.

powerboat · Shelter Island Heights

Peconic Water Sports (Shelter Island)

A pickup-only dock in the hamlet of Shelter Island Heights - the operator's own site says there is no on-site staff, so book online or by phone and the boat is waiting at the dock. Same rental fleet and wake-sports charters as the other Hamptons and North Fork locations.

Run a charter? See how referrals work.

Cross-reference the full On the Water guide.