Worth booking if this price tier and vibe match your trip — only if you aren't chasing a boutique experience elsewhere.
← Back to Where to stayHistoric inn · Sag Harbor · $$$
The American Hotel
CoupleFirst dateIn-lawsRomantic
45 Main Street, at the heart of Sag Harbor's Main Street. Ted Conklin bought the building, replaced the coal stove and opened his restaurant and hotel here on July 4, 1972. Rooms above a fine-dining room and a celebrated bar.
HistoricWalkable to townRomantic
Book it
- Address:
- 45 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
- On site:
- Restaurant on site · Bar on site
- Open:
- Year-round
- Good for:
- Couple · Returning regular
More places to stay near Sag Harbor
Source: The Southampton Press