Yes if you want Old Hamptons in one room — clubby bar, legendary wine list, and service that has been doing this for decades.

Breakfast restaurant · Sag Harbor · $$$$

The American Hotel (breakfast)

The Sag Harbor landmark since 1846. Sit-down breakfast in the dining room. Also a fine-dining restaurant, celebrated bar, and 8-room inn.

Source: The American Hotel official website. Last verified 2026-04-10.

Browse every spot on Coffee & Breakfast.