Only in season, and only after checking. A weekend pop-up inside a hotel, not a place to drive to on spec.

Café · Montauk · $$

Hole in the Wall at The Surf Lodge

Hole in the Wall's Australian brunch and HITW Coffee Co. run as a summer weekend residency at The Surf Lodge. The operator publishes no hours for the Montauk site — its own page says to check back in summer — so treat it as seasonal and call The Surf Lodge before going.

Source: Hole in the Wall official Montauk page. Last verified 2026-07-31.

Browse every spot on Coffee & Breakfast.