Café · Shelter Island
Stars Cafe
Opens 6 AMToday: 6 AM – 4 PM
Open at 6am every day but Christmas, with a full breakfast and lunch menu and pastries baked on site.
Year-round$$
Coffee & Breakfast
Coffee shops, bakeries, bagel counters, and early-bird breakfast spots locals actually go to.
5 AM6 AM7 AM8 AM9 AM10 AM11 AM
Filters9 breakfast spots
9 spots
- Café · Shelter Island
IGA Shelter Island
Opens 7 AMToday: 7 AM – 8 PMOpen Mon-Sun 7am-8pm.
Year-round$$ - Café · Shelter IslandSeated dining
The Chequit
Opens 7 AMToday: 7 AM – 3 PMThe Heights Cafe — Brooklyn Roasting Co. coffee and pastries.
Year-round$$ - Bagel shop · Shelter Island
The Eccentric Bagel
Opens 7 AMToday: 7 AM – 2 PMOpen Mon-Thu 7am-2pm, Fri-Sat 7am-3pm, Sun 7am-2pm.
Year-round$$ - Breakfast restaurant · Shelter IslandSeating unconfirmed
The Islander
Call ahead for hours
Breakfast and lunch seven days a week, year-round.
Year-round$$ - Café · Shelter IslandSeating unconfirmed
Maria's Kitchen
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 8 PMNorth Ferry Road kitchen open seven days a week — 8am to 8pm in summer, 9am to 7pm in winter.
Year-round$$ - Café · Shelter IslandSeating unconfirmed
Opties and Dinghies
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 9 PMOpen Mon-Sun 8am-9pm.
Year-round$$$ - Bakery · Shelter IslandSeating unconfirmed
Kyle's
Call ahead for hours
Hours: Mon-Fri closed, Sat-Sun 8am-3pm.
Year-round$$ - Café · Shelter IslandSeating unconfirmed
Marie Eiffel Market
Call ahead for hours
On 184 N Ferry Rd.
Year-round$$
☕ Coffee: cafés, bakeries, bagels, roasters
Cafes and roasters
Coffee shops, bakeries, bagel joints, and roasters
8 of the spots above are coffee-first rather than sit-down breakfast. By region, then by kind; earliest opener first within each town.