Skip to main content

Hamptons Verified

Plan
Ask AI
Calendar
Saved

Tell the editor

Goes straight to a human. Not a public comment.

Hamptons Verified

About

How we work
For media

Practical

Where to stay
Install the app
Ask AI · connect your assistant

Yours

Sign in

Talk to us

Contact us
Suggest a place
Corrections
For operators
Newsletter

About

How we work
For media

Practical

Where to stay
Install the app
Ask AI · connect your assistant

Yours

Sign in

Talk to us

Contact us
Suggest a place
Corrections
For operators
Newsletter

© 2026 Hamptons Verified

Terms
Privacy
Cookies

Independently run. No affiliate links.

← Back to restaurants

Shelter Island

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

Seafood · $$

41 Smith St, Shelter Island.

Address

41 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

Phone

(631) 749-1851

Town

Shelter Island

Price

$$