Caribbean

Island-inspired plates and a rum bar on Canoe Place Road; rum punch brunch 11am–3pm weekends.

The West Montauk Highway Caribbean room that traded as Karamba until a 2017 court settlement over the name sent it to Guava Tropical. guavarestaurant.com now shows an unconfigured hosting page. The operator's site is gone, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 26 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, renewed 2026-02-03 and current to 2028-02-29.