Italian

The Hamptons institution. Wood-fired everything, garden vegetables, and a guest list that spans presidents to publishers.

Hand-rolled pasta, southern Italian classics, and a sceney bar that hums year-round.

Milanese power-lunch on Main Street. Order the risotto and people-watch.

Milanese trattoria with thin-crust pizza, kid-friendly patio, year-round hours.

The NoHo institution's Hamptons outpost. Whole-fish grilling, hand-cut pasta, scene-y but earned.

Since 1973. Red sauce, Chianti bottles on the walls, and the sweetest year-round date night in Sag.

Hill Street Italian with a wood-fired oven; 11am to 8pm, and to 9pm Fridays and Saturdays.

Italian and modern Mediterranean on Main Street, est. 2020; noon to 9pm, to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays.

Gambino-family Italian on Hampton Road since 1974 — no reservations, patio April to October, shut January and February.

Noyac Road pizza bar, dinner only; 5pm to 9pm Thursday to Monday and to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays, closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

American Pie of Southampton, out on the County Road 39 strip. Its state permit here is a temporary retail one issued 2026-03-12 and running to 2026-09-08, so this is a lighter existence check than the rest of the file. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State temporary retail permit at 850 County Road 39, Southampton, renewed 2026-03-12 and current to 2026-09-08.

County Road 39 pizza, pasta and heroes with curbside pickup; 10:30am to 9:30pm daily.

Hampton Road pizza and deli with an early breakfast counter; Monday to Saturday 5am to 3pm, closed Sunday.

Wood-fired pizza and Italian classics on Three Mile Harbor Road; dinner from 5pm, closed Tuesdays.

Railroad Avenue Italian deli and prepared foods, 7am to 8pm and to 7pm Sundays.

Pantigo Road Italian deli — 10:30am to 6:45pm, and to 4pm Sundays.

Park Place pizzeria since 1983, open every day 10am to 9pm.

Springs Fireplace Road pizzeria with a full Italian menu; indoor and outdoor seating.

Springs Fireplace Road pizzeria, 11am to 9pm and to 8pm Sundays.

Montauk Highway deli and pizzeria, 5:30am to 10pm daily.

3360 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor.

Fort Pond Italian since 1994 — local seafood and garden produce, dinner nightly from 5pm; the patio is walk-up only.

Edgemere Street Italian serving breakfast, lunch and dinner.

Montauk Highway Italian with a pantry attached — noon to 9:30pm, brunch from Memorial Day to Labor Day.

West Lake Drive Italian and bar — gourmet brick-oven pizza, pasta and steaks, family-friendly.

Montauk Highway pizza and pasta counter.

Montauk Highway pizzeria — 11am to 8pm, to 9pm Fridays and Saturdays.

South Erie Avenue branch of the East Hampton pizzeria, open every day 11am to 9pm.

2402 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton.

American Pie of the Hamptons' Bridgehampton pizzeria, by the King Kullen plaza on Montauk Highway. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 2044 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, renewed 2025-06-10 and current to 2027-06-30.

2123 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton.

Main Street slice shop from the Brooklyn group — Friday to Sunday, noon to 9pm.

Montauk Highway pizzeria and Italian kitchen — specialty pies only, more than twenty years in Wainscott.

Ponquogue Avenue pizzeria and Italian kitchen, delivering seven days.

Long-running Italian dining room on West Montauk Highway; porch tables, call to book.

Italian market and dining room since 1997 — house mozzarella, sauces, sausage, focaccia.

Hampton Bays pizzeria since 1968; closed only on Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Family pizzeria on West Montauk Highway serving Italian and Latin dishes.

Chain pizza delivery and carryout on West Montauk Highway.

Main Street pizzeria, wine bar and cafe; summer service from 5pm on weekdays.

Montauk Highway Italian restaurant and pizzeria; open all year but three holidays.

Pizzeria on Old Riverhead Road. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 88 90 Old Riverhead Rd, Westhampton Beach, renewed 2025-06-06 and current to 2027-03-31.

Formerly Firehouse Pizza — Montauk Highway pizzeria with Italian and Latin American plates.

Montauk Highway pizza and deli from 5am — heroes, breakfast, steam table, catering.

135 3rd St, Greenport.

Greenport pizza bar on Main Street from the Rolling in Dough group; noon to 9pm, to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays, closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

53345 Main Rd, Southold.

County Road 48 pizzeria doing slices, pies and heroes; 11am to 8:30pm every day.

13550 Main Rd, Mattituck.

55 Middle Rd, Mattituck.

10095 Main Rd, Mattituck.

Main Road pizzeria in the middle of Mattituck — slices, pies and heroes. Closed Sundays.

28350 Main Rd, Cutchogue.

31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue.

Cucina Alba's East End debut sits dockside at Montauk Yacht Club: coastal Italian around the day's catch, a raw bar, and an easy-drinking wine list with boats a few feet from the tables. Time it for sunset over the water.

Italian coastal kitchen and cocktails at the Inn Spot, with dinner nightly except Tuesdays and weekend service from noon.

Sicilian farm-to-table cooking from Palermo-born chef-owner John Gambino, in a restored 1830s house with garden seating on the North Fork wine trail.

Amalfi-inspired dining room at Faraway Sag Harbor, the former Baron's Cove, where chef Jarad McCarroll's menu balances East End ingredients with the flavors of the Mediterranean. Opened with the hotel's summer 2026 relaunch; no published opening hours — book through the hotel's SevenRooms page.

The East Hampton camp of NYC's Rubirosa — the 60-year-old New York-style thin-crust recipe and the tie-dye pie, plus handmade pasta and a dog-friendly patio, in the Race Lane space. Dinner only, Resy, no phone.