Mexican

Roadside taqueria from the Nick & Toni's family. Order the chiles rellenos.

West Coast-leaning tacos and cocktails on Hampton Road; 11am to 9pm, to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays.

Jagger Lane Mexican grill, seven days; 10am to 8pm Mondays, to 9pm midweek, to 10pm at weekends.

50A Montauk Hwy, Southampton.

138 Division St, Sag Harbor.

Taco Ole Inc took a fresh state restaurant licence at Suite 2, 805 Montauk Highway in April 2026. eltacoole.com no longer resolves. The operator's site is gone, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 805 Montauk Hwy Ste 2, Montauk, renewed 2026-04-22 and current to 2028-03-31.

10 S Etna Ave, Montauk.

Mexican grill on the Water Mill stretch of Montauk Highway. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 1152 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, renewed 2025-07-23 and current to 2027-06-30.

Chef Miguel's traditional Mexican kitchen in Hampton Bays; closed Sundays.

Taquería and deli on East Montauk Highway, sibling to the Westhampton dining room.

Main Street Mexican grill, open all year, seven days; off-season closes an hour earlier.

Old Riverhead Road Mexican dining room; closed Mondays.

Fajitas and tacos on Main Street — the Westhampton Beach half of a two-shop operation whose other kitchen is on West Main Street in Riverhead. The operator publishes 11am–8pm Sunday to Thursday and 11am–9pm Friday and Saturday. New York State restaurant licence at 127 Main St, Westhampton Beach, renewed 2025-09-03 and current to 2027-08-31.

119 Main St, Greenport.

Left 110 Front Street on 27 December 2025 and reopened in the Sterlington Hotel building on Third Street; hours not published since the move.

131 3rd St, Greenport.

44780 Middle Rd, Southold.

10560 Main Rd, Mattituck.

Montauk branch of the Southampton taqueria, in the Breakers hotel on Old Montauk Highway, with its own menu and online ordering.