Steakhouse

The classic NYC steakhouse on Main Street East Hampton. Steak for two, no surprises.

The Truman Capote bar of the South Fork. Steaks, martinis, and a long literary shadow.

Montauk Highway outpost of the Lucky's steakhouse group — Sunday noon to 9:30pm, Monday to Thursday 5 to 9:30pm, Friday 5 to 10:30pm, Saturday noon to 10:30pm.

A family-run steakhouse and tavern on the Noyac Road strip — burgers, steaks, fajitas and nightly specials, in its own words. The site publishes no address, phone or hours; the address here is the state's. Call ahead. New York State on-premises licence at 3360 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor, renewed 2026-05-08 and current to 2028-05-31.

Steakhouse on the western end of West Montauk Highway. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 322 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, renewed 2026-01-13 and current to 2028-01-31.