Worth booking if this price tier and vibe match your trip — only if you aren't chasing a boutique experience elsewhere.
← Back to Where to stayBoutique inn · Amagansett · $$$$
The Reform Club
CoupleFirst dateIn-lawsRomantic
Eleven keys on Windmill Lane — seven suites in the main inn, three private cottages and the four-bedroom 21 House — set among gardens and apple and pear orchards, plus the Meeting House restaurant.
Quiet luxuryDesign-forward
Book it
- Address:
- 23 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11937
- Phone:
- +1 631-267-8500
- On site:
- Restaurant on site
- Open:
- Summer-only
- Good for:
- Couple · Returning regular
More places to stay near Amagansett
Source: Hotel/operator official sites