Stay
The Hamptons is not one place. Pick the village that matches your temperament first; the bed comes after.
Where they are
Every hotel, inn, and campground on the map. Tap a marker for the full card and booking links.
- Boutique / historic inn
- Resort / oceanfront
- Cottages / B&B
- Modern boutique
- Camping
Town personalities
Amagansett
Quiet. Two blocks of Main Street. Don't blink.quiet · tiny · farm-to-table · beachyShowHide
quiet · tiny · farm-to-table · beachy
Wedged between East Hampton and Montauk. The smallest of the major hamlets and proud of it. Stephen Talkhouse for live music, Indian Wells and Atlantic Avenue for the ocean beaches, the green at Amagansett Square, and the Amagansett Farmers Market a short walk on from it.
Good for: Couples who want to disappear, Indian Wells Beach.
Skip if: You need nightlife or shopping.
Hotels & inns
We do not book for you. Use this as a shortlist.
8 places
Amagansett · 8 places
Amagansett · Cottages
Rooms in a fully renovated 100-year-old barn, a historic two-storey main house on Amagansett's tree-lined Main Street, and an off-site Beach House in the Amagansett Dunes built in the 1960s by architect Alfred Scheffer.
Quiet luxuryRomanticThe Reform Club
$$$$Amagansett · Boutique inn
Eleven keys on Windmill Lane — seven suites in the main inn, three private cottages and the four-bedroom 21 House — set among gardens and apple and pear orchards, plus the Meeting House restaurant.
Quiet luxuryDesign-forwardAmagansett · Inn / hotel
Dune Resorts property on Montauk Highway in Amagansett, open for the 2026 season.
Amagansett · Inn / hotel
Dune Resorts oceanfront property on Montauk Highway in Amagansett, open for the 2026 season.
Amagansett · Inn / hotel
Oceanfront resort motel at 28 Shore Road on the Amagansett dunes. Six room and efficiency types, all air conditioned; high season runs June 12 to September 7.
Amagansett · Inn / hotel
Beach resort on Montauk Highway in Amagansett, a short drive from the ocean beaches.