Breakfast counter · Sag Harbor
Cove Delicatessen
Opens 6 AMToday: 6 AM – 6 PM
Open Mon-Sat 6am-6pm, Sun 6am-3pm.
Year-round$
Coffee & Breakfast
Coffee shops, bakeries, bagel counters, and early-bird breakfast spots locals actually go to.
5 AM6 AM7 AM8 AM9 AM10 AM11 AM
Filters12 breakfast spots
12 spots
- Bagel shop · Sag Harbor
Goldberg's Famous Bagels (Sag Harbor)
Opens 6 AMToday: 6 AM – 4 PMThe Sag Harbor Main St branch of the Original Goldberg's.
Year-round$ - Café · Sag Harbor
Sagtown
Opens 6 AMToday: 6 AM – 5 PMSag Harbor's Main Street coffee counter — espresso, specialty drinks, breakfast and lunch — plus Sagtown Apres, wine, beer and…
Year-roundOutdoor$$ - Café · Sag Harbor
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
Opens 7 AMToday: 7 AM – 3 PMBrioche and cake donuts, strong coffee and a lot of cold brew, open year-round on Main Street since 2016.
Year-round$$ - Café · Sag Harbor
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee (Sag Harbor)
Opens 7 AMToday: 7 AM – 4 PMJack's organic stir-brewed coffee arrived on Sag Harbor Main St with the same vegan apple-cider donuts and plant-based pastries as…
Year-roundOutdoor$$ - Café · Sag HarborSeating unconfirmed
Harbor Market and Kitchen
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 6 PMNeighborhood market and take-out kitchen on Division Street.
Year-round$$$ - Café · Sag Harbor
Provisions Natural Foods Market & Organic Cafe
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 6 PMSag Harbor's 30-year natural foods market with a full organic cafe.
Year-round$$ - Café · Sag Harbor
SunLife Organics
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 3 PMThe California smoothie chain that opened in the former Estia's Little Kitchen space on the Turnpike in late May 2026…
$$ - Breakfast restaurant · Sag Harbor
The American Hotel (breakfast)
Opens 8 AMToday: 8 AM – 10 PMThe Sag Harbor landmark since 1846.
Year-round$$$$
☕ Coffee: cafés, bakeries, bagels, roasters
Cafes and roasters
Coffee shops, bakeries, bagel joints, and roasters
9 of the spots above are coffee-first rather than sit-down breakfast. By region, then by kind; earliest opener first within each town.
9 coffee spots