Hamptons Verified

Photo coming soon — we're sourcing a verified image for this entry.

Worth it for the bar side on a Sunday in season — skip the dining room if you wanted somewhere loud, because the two halves are not the same restaurant.

Back to Nightlife
bar · New Suffolk

Legends

Two rooms at the end of a North Fork lane — a white-tablecloth dining side and a beer-hall bar with a long draught list and a Sunday football special.

Address:
835 1st St, New Suffolk, NY 11956
Hours:
Dining Sun–Thu noon–9p, Fri–Sat noon–9:30p; bar and late menu an hour later

Source: NYS Liquor Authority active licence register — 835 1st Street Corp dba Legends, 835 1st St New Suffolk — restaurant licence, expires 2026-09-30

Goes straight to a human. Not a public comment.