Photo coming soon — we're sourcing a verified image for this entry.

Worth booking if you know what you want from the Brookhaven — only if your party actually cares about being on the boat.

fishing · East Moriches

Silly Lily Fishing Station

Parent location of the Lily's operation — just west of the Shinnecock Canal on Moriches Bay. Daily and package rentals (~$219/day), Sunset Dinner Cruise on Tuthill Cove, Oyster Farm Tour with wine pairing at Sue Wicks's farm, Eco Bay kayak tour, and Curated Beach Day skiff trips. Lily's Sailing School and Lily's Seaside restaurant on-site. Silly Club loyalty card ($50/year) for 10% off. 10th anniversary under current ownership in January 2026.

Cross-reference the full On the Water guide.