Seafood

Fried clams, lobster rolls, and chowder in a no-frills shack the kids will remember.

Sam McCleland's waterfront seafood spot on Mill Creek — crab cakes, raw bar, harbor views.

The 'LUNCH' sign you've seen in every Hamptons movie. Lobster rolls on the Napeague stretch. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, renewed 2026-04-23 and current to 2028-03-31.

Napeague roadside fish shack — fried clams, lobster rolls and chowder; 11:30am to 8pm, an hour later Fridays and Saturdays.

Fish market with a counter. Fried fish sandwich is the cheat code. (Formerly Cor-J Seafood.)

Sunset over Fort Pond Bay with a $98 lobster cobb. Wear linen, pretend to be unbothered.

Salivar's Dock seafood house on West Lake Drive — open 4pm for dinner, seven nights a week.

The LUNCH operation's Southampton room, on the Montauk Highway edge of the village. The operator's site is behind a bot wall we cannot read, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State restaurant licence at 32 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, renewed 2026-04-23 and current to 2028-04-30.

Lobster rolls and local catch on Inlet Road; 10am to 8pm, to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays, and shorter out of season.

North Sea Road seafood market, caterer and takeaway; 10am to 6:30pm, to 7pm Fridays and Saturdays.

West Lake Drive seafood house — open seven days, 11:30am to 9pm.

East Lake Drive restaurant built by six Montauk fishermen over their own dock — no reservations, just drop in.

2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk.

Montauk Highway lobster counter, noon to 9pm daily.

Oak Lane fish market, open daily 9am to 8pm.

Cranberry Hole Road seafood market and net-pen farm — lobster rolls, Promised Land oysters, farm-raised striped bass.

Montauk Highway fish market and caterer, thirty-plus years in Wainscott.

Waterfront New American beside the Shinnecock Canal; weekend brunch 11am–3pm.

Shinnecock Canal seafood — first come, first served, no reservations; closed Tuesdays.

Dune Road waterfront seafood on Shinnecock Bay, seven days a week year-round.

Hampton Bays fish market, restaurant and wholesaler; open daily until 9pm.

Lobster-bake and clambake caterer on Lighthouse Road — events only, no dining room.

Excelsior Fish Corp trades as Haskell's Seafood at 77A–77B Main Street on a state licence taken in February 2026. haskellsseafood.com no longer resolves. The operator's site is gone, so no hours are published here — call ahead. New York State on-premises licence at 77A 77B Main St, Westhampton Beach, renewed 2026-02-06 and current to 2028-01-31.

Mill Road fish market since 1982 — local and imported fish, prepared food, catering.

Potunk Lane oyster grower selling Long Island oysters retail and wholesale, weekdays 10am–5pm.

64 Old Country Rd, Quogue.

41 Smith St, Shelter Island.

87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island.

58775 County Rd 48, Greenport.

211 Carpenter St, Greenport.

27 Front St, Greenport.

50 N Sea Dr, Southold.

62300 Main Rd, Southold.

Charlie Manwaring's fish market on County Road 25, twenty-six years in his hands; hours not published.

30840 Main Rd, Cutchogue.

Gosman's Dock's newest counter, opened May 2026: lobsters, steamers and clam-bar classics on West Lake Drive with the working harbor in view. Distinct from MTK Lobster House on the highway.

Family seafood house on the west side of Lake Montauk, with a sushi section on the dinner menu and a take-out counter of chowders, fried fish and lobster. No reservations — first come, first served.

Casual breakfast, lunch and dinner over Montauk Harbor at the Star Island Yacht Club, with dockage at lunch and dinner and a you-hook-'em-we-cook-'em service for your own catch.

Family-run seafood counter a block from the beach: local fish fried or grilled, steamers, lobster rolls and chowders, eaten at the picnic tables outside or taken away.

Thirty-odd years of raw bar, whole lobster and Bonac steamers on Three Mile Harbor, with the sunset doing most of the decorating. Dinner only from 5, closed Tuesdays, indoor and outdoor tables — and no reservations, so turn up.

650 1st St, New Suffolk — the North Fork, not Shelter Island.