Seafood

Fried clams, lobster rolls, and chowder in a no-frills shack the kids will remember.

Sam McCleland's waterfront seafood spot on Mill Creek — crab cakes, raw bar, harbor views.

The 'LUNCH' sign you've seen in every Hamptons movie.

Napeague roadside fish shack — fried clams, lobster rolls and chowder; 11:30am to 8pm, an hour later Fridays and Saturdays.

Fish market with a counter.

Sunset over Fort Pond Bay with a $98 lobster cobb.

Salivar's Dock seafood house on West Lake Drive — open 4pm for dinner, seven nights a week.

The LUNCH operation's Southampton room, on the Montauk Highway edge of the village.

Lobster rolls and local catch on Inlet Road; 10am to 8pm, to 10pm Fridays and Saturdays, and shorter out of…

North Sea Road seafood market, caterer and takeaway; 10am to 6:30pm, to 7pm Fridays and Saturdays.

West Lake Drive seafood house — open seven days, 11:30am to 9pm.

East Lake Drive restaurant built by six Montauk fishermen over their own dock — no reservations, just drop in.

2 S Debusy Rd, Montauk.

Montauk Highway lobster counter, noon to 9pm daily.

Oak Lane fish market, open daily 9am to 8pm.

Cranberry Hole Road seafood market and net-pen farm — lobster rolls, Promised Land oysters, farm-raised striped bass.

Montauk Highway fish market and caterer, thirty-plus years in Wainscott.

Waterfront New American beside the Shinnecock Canal; weekend brunch 11am–3pm.

Shinnecock Canal seafood — first come, first served, no reservations; closed Tuesdays.

Dune Road waterfront seafood on Shinnecock Bay, seven days a week year-round.

Hampton Bays fish market, restaurant and wholesaler; open daily until 9pm.

Lobster-bake and clambake caterer on Lighthouse Road — events only, no dining room.

Excelsior Fish Corp trades as Haskell's Seafood at 77A–77B Main Street on a state licence taken in February 2026. haskellsseafood.com…

Mill Road fish market since 1982 — local and imported fish, prepared food, catering.

64 Old Country Rd, Quogue.

41 Smith St, Shelter Island.

87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island.

58775 County Rd 48, Greenport.

211 Carpenter St, Greenport.

27 Front St, Greenport.

50 N Sea Dr, Southold.

62300 Main Rd, Southold.

Charlie Manwaring's fish market on County Road 25, twenty-six years in his hands; hours not published.

30840 Main Rd, Cutchogue.

Gosman's Dock's newest counter, opened May 2026: lobsters, steamers and clam-bar classics on West Lake Drive with the working harbor…

Family seafood house on the west side of Lake Montauk, with a sushi section on the dinner menu and a…

Casual breakfast, lunch and dinner over Montauk Harbor at the Star Island Yacht Club, with dockage at lunch and dinner…

Family-run seafood counter a block from the beach: local fish fried or grilled, steamers, lobster rolls and chowders, eaten at…

Thirty-odd years of raw bar, whole lobster and Bonac steamers on Three Mile Harbor, with the sunset doing most of…

650 1st St, New Suffolk — the North Fork, not Shelter Island.

Family-owned seafood restaurant on East Main Street since 1994, now under second-generation ownership, with a waterfront patio near the Long…