Photo coming soon — we're sourcing a verified image for this entry.

Yes — the best-stocked bar in the Hamptons, and nobody will rush you out of the leather chair.

Cocktail Bar · Sag Harbor

The American Hotel

Name: The American Hotel
Address: 49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, Sag Harbor, NY, US
Telephone: +1-631-725-3535

Historic 1846 Sag Harbor hotel bar with a legendary wine cellar and dark-wood tavern atmosphere. Also a fine-dining restaurant and 8-room inn.

Source: The American Hotel official site · Last verified 2026-04-08